Wednesday, August 03, 2011

a consistent ethic of life

This is just too freakin' good not to share....


Up to now, we have almost entirely emphasized personal sin, with little notion of what John Paul II rightly called “structural sin” or “institutional evil.” There has been little recognition of the deep connection between the structures that people uncritically accept and the personal evil things they also do.

The individual has usually gotten all the blame, while what Paul called the powers, the sovereignties, and the principalities (Romans 8:38, Colossians 2:15, Ephesians 3:10, 6:12) have gotten off scot-free for most of Christian history. Paul used rather brilliant pre-modern words for what we would now call institutions or juggernauts, or what President Eisenhower called the military-industrial complex. They have an absolute life (and death!) of their own that is usually above normal understanding and eludes any honest critique. In fact, we tend to worship them as mighty and strong, and therefore always good. “Too big to fail,” we now say.

For example, we idealize public, national wars. In fact, few things are more romanticized than war, except by those who suffer from them. At the same time, we rail against violence in the streets, the violence of our young people, and the violence on the news every night. We are slowly learning that we cannot have it both ways. If violence is a way to solve international problems, then it is a way to solve problems at home too. We can’t say it’s good here but it’s bad there. We know how to name individual sin and evil, but we do not know how to name corporate sin and evil. We have ended up with a very inconsistent morality, which few take seriously any more or even know how to follow. That is why we need a consistent ethic of life.

Richard Rohr


Sandi said...

This was certainly something to think about. While I personally abhor all violence, I realize that isn't very realistic. I've never felt that war was the way to compromise, yet, it's been around forever. I'm probably just burying my head in the sand . . . I guess because it hurts to think about the consequences of war and violence.
I don't know any answers, but I appreciate the post!

kario said...

That last paragraph is the kicker, isn't it? Thanks for sharing it with us. I love this community where we all find bits of wisdom and pass them along. Such a treasure!